Hardware security keys (a pair of FIDO2 keys)
A small USB and tap-to-phone key that proves it's really you when you sign in, and simply refuses to work on a fake login page.
01When it saves you
Your email account resets the password on almost everything else, including the accounts that hold your money. When a convincing text says your parcel is stuck or your bank needs you to log in, a fake page can capture your password and the six-digit code you type. A security key has nothing to type, so there is nothing to hand over. And if your phone is lost, stolen or broken, the key still gets you into your email.
02How it works
When you add the key to an account, it makes a secret that belongs to that one website address. Later, the key only answers if the site really is that address. A lookalike site at a different address gets nothing, however perfect it looks. This is why the FIDO standard behind it is called phishing resistant (phishing means tricking you into a fake login page).
You touch the key, or tap it on the back of your phone, and sometimes type a short PIN for the key. It has no battery and no internet connection. One key can also hold passkeys, which let you sign in with no password at all.
You buy two and register both on every account. One lives on your keyring, the other stays at home or with someone you trust. Apple insists on at least two for exactly this reason: lose your only key and your only devices, and you can be locked out for good.
03What to buy
Made by the best-known maker, waterproof and dustproof (IP68), works by USB or by tapping on an NFC phone, and holds up to 100 passkeys. It does the FIDO2 job every big service uses and nothing else, which is all most people need.
Where: Yubico's own UK store. Pick USB-A or USB-C to match your laptop; both versions tap on phones.
A FIDO2.1 key with NFC in a metal frame, for a little less. Token2 ships from Switzerland or the EU, so allow for delivery time and possible import charges.
Where: Token2's own shop.
Does everything the Security Key does, plus older and work-style sign-in methods (one-time codes, smart card, OpenPGP). Worth it only if your job or a specific service asks for those extras.
Where: Yubico's own UK store.
Avoid
- Buying one key. If it's lost or broken you're back to codes, or locked out. Always register two.
- Second-hand keys, or no-name keys that aren't FIDO Certified. Apple, for one, only accepts FIDO Certified keys.
- Older keys that only do U2F (the first FIDO version). Google accepts them as a second step, but a key must support FIDO2 to hold passkeys.
- A USB-A only key if all your devices are USB-C, unless you're happy to rely on tapping with NFC.
04You’ll also need
- Ten minutes per account and a list of your most important ones: main email first, then Apple or Google, Microsoft, your password manager, PayPal and social media.
- Printed or written backup codes for each account, kept with your paper documents.
- A keyring for key one, and a safe place (a drawer at home or a relative's house) for key two.
!Limits, honestly
- Not every service supports keys. UK banks mostly use their own app approval instead, so for banking the protection is your phone's lock and the banking app itself.
- Google says a newly added key may take up to 7 days before it's offered at sign-in, so don't wait for an emergency to set it up.
- A key protects sign-in. It can't stop you approving a payment or reading out a code to a scammer on the phone.